should the smiths reform ?

[pandora_cocteau]

no no no noooooooo

some things are sacred. the smiths being one of them. it just wouldn't be the same the second time around. more over, it would diminish the legend that was...in my opinion. too much history and animosity between the members....

 

[dothewatusi]

I feel that they shouldn't...most reformations is normally awful and they only really appeal to the nostalga crowd

Nostalga crowd...how rude!

 

[vivabob]

For the interest of people who missed earlier threads about the same subject:

What would pay to see a Smiths reunion concert?
http://forums.morrissey-solo.com/showthread.php?t=72591

Which Morrissey related reunion would you prefer?
http://forums.morrissey-solo.com/showthread.php?t=72354

Do you want Smiths to reunite?
http://forums.morrissey-solo.com/showthread.php?t=76521

i did have a look for the through the threads but when i posted i was looking for a poll and couldnt find one

to be honest i am happy with the results so far

but agree with sns22's comment
But a benefit show for charity...sure, why not...

as long as its a one off

 

[vivabob]

Nostalga crowd...how rude!

it wasnt meant to be rude but who goes to see the sex pistols , the police , the who , rolling stones NOW its not people looking to see something new its the same people who like a bit of nostalga , play the hits and think of your youth type people