Morrissey-solo
Archive
|
|
|||||||||
posted by
davidt
on Sunday January 13 2002, @12:00PM
Bryan Hayes was the first to write:
Here's the link for the story: Beatles, Ramones -- Spin Magazine's Rock Greatest This is the blurb about the Smiths: The criteria for the 50 greatest were that "these groups had to have a roof-raising, history-changing sound, presence or hairstyle.'' In addition, "they also had to clearly influence today's music in undeniable ways'' and "had to be bands that we care about deeply.'' That might explain why acclaimed bands like U2 (13th greatest), The Grateful Dead (27th), The Who (39th), The Beach Boys (45th) and Pink Floyd (49th) are rated lower in the Top 50 than lesser known but arguably more influential groups like The Smiths (21st), Pavement (30th), Fugazi (31st) or New Order (41st). The full list (via a comment on MetaFilter): 1. THE BEATLES 2. RAMONES 3. LED ZEPPELIN 4. BOB MARLEY & THE WAILERS 5. NIRVANA 6. PARLIAMENT/FUNKADELIC 7. THE CLASH 8. PUBLIC ENEMY 9. THE ROLLING STONES 10. BEASTIE BOYS 11. THE VELVET UNDERGROUND 12. SLY AND THE FAMILY STONE 13. U2 14. RUN-D.M.C. 15. RADIOHEAD 16. THE JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE 17. SONIC YOUTH 18. AC/DC 19. THE STOOGES 20. METALLICA 21. THE SMITHS 22. PATTI SMITH GROUP 23. N.W.A. 24. KRAFTWERK 25. THE SEX PISTOLS 26. PEARL JAM 27. GRATEFUL DEAD 28. R.E.M. 29. BLACK SABBATH 30. PAVEMENT 31. FUGAZI 32. KISS 33. PRETENDERS 34. RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE 35. FELA KUTI & AFRIKA 70/EGYPT 80 36. DAVID BOWIE AND THE SPIDERS FROM MARS 37. BLONDIE 38. BAD BRAINS 39. THE WHO 40. GRANDMASTER FLASH & THE FURIOUS FIVE 41. NEW ORDER 42. HUSKER DU 43. GUNS N' ROSES 44. OUTKAST 45. THE BEACH BOYS 46. MASSIVE ATTACK 47. LYNYRD SKYNYRD 48. KORN 49. PINK FLOYD 50. RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
Smiths #21 in Spin's Top 50 Rock Bands of All Time (Feb. issue)
| Top
| 35 comments
| Search Discussion
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
|
|||||||||
|
Top 10-50-100 lists in mags and Newt Gingrich..... (Score:2, Troll)
That said, I'm glad Smiths made the list anyway.
(User #2464 Info)
Not all that irrelevant (Score:1)
(User #2224 Info)
Hmmm! (Score:0)
the rankings may be messed up.... (Score:1)
good for them.
(User #837 Info)
Just another bogus list by bogus folks (Score:1)
PS. Where the *f* are The Monkeys?
(User #100 Info)
Re:Just another bogus list by bogus folks (Score:2, Interesting)
Look at Spin's list--how many of those artists truly belong, and how many are there to assuage a perverse sense of inclusion?
Numbers 12, 23, 31, 35, 42, 47 and 48 come to mind...
And how can Guided By Voices, Blur and Talking Heads! not be on the list?
American magazines rarely get it right...
(User #27 Info)
Parent
ive seen another funny poll (Score:1)
the stones at no.9 when the beatles get no.1...
call me cynical but if mick had died in the seventies the stones would be at no.1 or 2.
mind u this is an american list, (hence the unknown in the u.k. 'bad brains)...
(User #1028 Info)
Metallica (Score:1)
(User #1342 Info)
Confusion (Score:1)
Oh...and the Mode and Roxy Music, surely? Somewhere?
(User #1359 Info | http://www.kraftwerk.com/)
Korn??!! (Score:1)
Their very first album wasn't horrible, unlistenable angst-for-money formulaic TRIPE like the next three, which got progressively more ridiculous with each release. That's the nicest thing I can say about them...ugh. enough
Spin's lists are usually at least fifty percent bullsh*t anyway. I'm not exactly surprised...I get the feeling they're just trying to make it 'diverse' while actual musical content/relevance to their poll comes second...it means nothing.
They really like the Smiths, though. At least they got something right...if you look, every issue contains at least one Morrissey/Smiths reference in their article titles or little captions for photos. Obviously they respect them, to sprinkle them so liberally all over their magazine all the time...makes me think their place on the list might have not been completely arbitrary.
Did anyone see their list of the 50 most essential punk bands? What a riot....!!
(User #3874 Info)
Depeche Mode? (Score:1)
(User #2756 Info)
Ha Ha Americans are dopey (Score:0)
Useless Useless Useless (Score:0)
And where the hell is Bauhaus!?! Seem to fit all of the criteria, and spawned the whole goth thing...
Kraftwerk, New Order, Depeche Mode should all be higher or at least included given electronica's widespread appeal these days.
Another US mag fucks up again...